London Open Mic Poetry Archive
  • Home
  • Frank Davey Blog
  • Stan Burfield Blog
    • Fred Burfield's Homestead Memoirs
  • Our Events
  • News
  • PHOTOS & SUMMARIES
    • Season 5: 2016-2017 >
      • June 7th, 2017: Summary & Photos featuring Stan Burfield
      • May 3rd, 2017, Summary & Photos featuring Jason Dickson
      • April 5th, 2017 Summary & Photos, feeaturing James Deahl & Norma West Linder
      • Mar. 1st, 2017: Photos & Summary featuring Andy Verboom
      • Feb. 1st, 2017: Photos & Summary featuring Ron Stewart
      • Dec. 7th, 2016: Photos & Summary featuring David Stones
      • Nov. 2th, 2016: Photos and Summary featuring Don Gutteridge
      • Oct. 5th, 2016: Photos and Summary featuring David Huebert
    • Season 4: 2015-2016 >
      • June 1st, 2016: Photos and summaries: featuring Lynn Tait
      • May 4th, 2016 Photos and Summary: featuring indigenous poetry
      • April 6, 2016 Photos & Summary, featuring Steven McCabe
      • Mar. 2nd, 2016 photos, summary: featuring Andreas Gripp
      • Feb. 3rd, 2016 photos: 3 Western students.
      • Dec. 2, 2015 photos: featured reader Peggy Roffey
      • Nov. 7, 2015 photos: Our Words Fest open mic
      • Nov. 4, 2015 photos: featured reader Charles Mountford
      • Oct. 7th, 2015 photos: Madeline Bassnett featured
    • Season 3, 2014-15 >
      • Aug. 16, 2015 photos: The Ontario Poetry Society's "Sultry Summer Gathering"
      • June 3rd, 2015 photos: John B. Lee featured
      • May 6th, 2015 photos: Laurie D Graham featured
      • Apr. 1st, 2015 photos: John Nyman & Penn Kemp featured
      • Mar. 4th, 2015 photos: Patricia Black featured.
      • Feb. 4th, 2015 photos: feature Gary Barwin
      • Dec. 3rd, 2014 photos: Feature Debbie Okun Hill
      • Nov. 5th, 2014 photos: feature Julie Berry
      • Oct. 1st, 2014 photos: feature Roy MacDonald
    • Season 2, Sept. 2013 to June 2014. >
      • June 4th, 20114, featuring Monika Lee
      • May 7th 2014, featuring Susan McCaslin and Lee Johnson
      • Sept. 4th, 2013 featuring Frank Beltrano
      • April 16th, 2014, featuring Penn Kemp and Laurence Hutchman
      • March 5th, 2014, featuring Jacob Scheier
      • Feb. 5th, 2014: featuring four UWO students of poetry; music by Tim Woodcock
      • Jan. 2nd, 2014: featuring Carrie Lee Connel
      • Dec. 4th, 2013, featuring M. NourbeSe Philip
      • Nov. 6, 2013 , featuring Susan Downe
      • Oct. 2nd, 2013, featuring Jan Figurski
    • Season 1: Oct. 2012 to June 2013 >
      • June 4th, 2013 featuring David J. paul and the best-ever open mic
      • May 1st, 2013, featuring Sonia Halpern
      • Apr. 24, 2013 featuring Frank Davey & Tom Cull
      • Mar. 6th, 2013, featuring Christine Thorpe
      • Feb. 6th, 2013, featuring D'vorah Elias
      • Jan. 3rd. 2013: John Tyndall featured.
      • Dec. 5, 2012: RL Raymond featured
    • Dig These Hip Cats ... The Beats
  • Poet VIDEOS (open mic & featured readers)
    • 5th Season Videos (2016-2017)
    • 4th Season Videos (2015-16)
    • 3rd Season Videos (2014-2015)
    • 2nd Season (2013-2014) videos
  • BIOGRAPHIES - Featured poets & musicians
  • INTERVIEWS & POEMS (featured poets)
    • SEASON 6 - Interviews & Poems >
      • Kevin Shaw: Poem & Interview
      • David Janzen - Interview
    • SEASON 5 INTERVIEWS & POEMS
    • SEASON 4 INTERVIEWS AND POEMS
    • SEASON 3 INTERVIEWS AND POEMS
    • SEASON 2 INTERVIEWS & POEMS (only from Dec. 4th, 2013)
    • Season 1 INTERVIEWS & POEMS (& 1st half of Season 2) >
      • INTERVIEWS of Featured Poets
      • POEMS by Featured Poets (1st Season & to Nov. 2013)
  • Couplets: Poets in Dialogue
  • Future Events
  • Past Events
    • 5th Season: 2016-2017
    • Season 4: 2015-2016
    • Season 3: 2014-2015
    • Season Two: 2013-2014
    • Season One: 2012-2013
  • Who we Are
  • Testimonial
  • Our Mission
  • Links
  • Contact us

McGurl on the Rise of Creative Writing in the US #creativewriting

8/20/2013

0 Comments

 
Picture
Mark McGurl, The Program Era: Postwar Fiction and the Rise of Creative Writing. Harvard University Press, 2009, 2011.

In the late 1970s when I was teaching at York University in Toronto the dean of Arts asked me to attempt to create an undergraduate creative writing ‘program’ from the nine writing courses offered by four departments, two in Arts and two in Fine Arts. Logically enough, he proposed that the program would be administered by a “Coordinator”  who would oversee the necessary cooperation among the departments and faculties. By fall 1978 I had cobbled together an introductory course and two poetry workshops offered by the English department, two fiction courses offered by the Humanities Division, two playwriting courses offered by the Theatre Department, and two filmscript courses offered by the Film Department, together with a list of twentieth-century literature courses from which a student majoring in Creative Writing would have to take at least one, and had persuaded both faculties to accept the other faculty’s courses as in-faculty credits, and both to offer the new CW degree. Later the Humanities Division volunteered to contribute a new course in literary non-fiction.  

My thoughts at this time about the university teaching of Creative Writing were that students who were going to be independently writing poems, plays and stories while at university ought to be able to get course credit for their work, be shown ways of writing they might not have become aware of, and also receive some feed-back, much like publishing writers get feed-back from editors and book-reviewers. The new Program I also saw as one for students who were going be active writers regardless of whether their university was offering CW courses or a Program. So for me, unlike for the US programs examined here by McGurl, the issue of whether or not creative writing could be “taught” never seemed relevant. The students were already writers and needed only to be shown how large the possibilities for writing were. In the years that I was Coordinator, the assortment of celebrated instructors – Irving Layton, Eli Mandel, bpNichol, Miriam Waddington, Clark Blaise, Dave Godfrey, Don Coles, Mavor Moore – rarely consulted one another and probably wouldn’t have agreed on many aesthetic or ideological questions if they had. We had one meeting a year in which we mainly addressed administrative matters.

In The Program Era: Postwar Fiction and the Rise of Creative Writing, Mark McGurl’s understanding of “program” is a lot narrower. Here a writing program is assumed to be pedagogically coherent, to have aesthetic principles and goals. It is most often the creation of a single powerful administrator, such as Iowa’s Wilbur Schramm and Paul Engle or Stanford’s Wallace Stegner. It exists separate from the university’s literary and language departments, often as part of a Fine Arts department, and often in an antagonistic relationship to them. Although most of the programs are postgraduate, the student is not already a writer but instead someone who goes day after day to the writing workshop anxiously wondering “Am I a writer yet?” (398). 

With rather entertaining cynicism, McGurl sets out to examine these US creative writing programs in the context both of the kinds of writers and writing they have produced and of the shifting focuses of US culture during the 1930-2000 period. In both his subtitle and the book, however, it is difficult to determine which of these elements has his priority. The title, The Program Era, suggests that it creative writing, but the subtitle, “Postwar Fiction and the The Rise of Creative Writing,” implies that it may be postwar US fiction. – i.e. that it is post-Second-World-War fiction that has been programmatic and which has given rise to Creative Writing programs – a thesis which the book itself does not support.

Lengthy parts of the book offer readings of stories and novels by selected program graduates – Flannery O’Connor, Philip Roth, Thomas Pynchon, John Barth, Toni Morrison, Raymond Carver, Ken Kesey, Bharati Mukherjee, Joyce Carol Oates, Sandra Cisneros. These readings do indirectly suggest the effects that the teaching of creative writing can have, but leave unaddressed what readings of work by different graduates might have implied. McGurl offers little explanation for having selected one graduate rather than another and acknowledges that he is leaving numerous interesting writers undiscussed. “[T]he task of tracing the ‘lessons’ of creative writing from the classroom into the literary texts of the Program Era will be a somewhat indeterminate enterprise” he correctly predicts in his introduction (36). The Program Era is thus much less systematic than he implies the creative writing program methodology to have been. Overall, the book seems more successful as an irreverent study of US postwar culture than it is as one of either creative writing programs or postwar fiction.

The first two-thirds of The Program Era is organized around three creative writing clichés – “write what you know,” “show don’t tell” (to which McGurl assigns the period 1890-1960) and “find your voice (1960-1975). McGurl’s use of these cliches, despite knowing the extent to which most contemporary creative writing teachers try to avoid them, is a sign of his somewhat agonized bemusement toward his subject. The clichés, he finds, persist in new guises, as in the 1980s when programs encourages the children of ethic families to “find” an ethnic voice. “[T]he appeal of speaking for oneself or of having one’s voice heard, is obvious when it is considered as an act primarily of political self-representation” (260). McGurl can admire program-era results while mocking the methods that led to them. “[T]he extent to that creative writing represents a further incursion of consumerism into the academy, a ballooning enterprise of mass vanity and anti-intellectualism, it needs to be described as such” (74).  “[A] discipline concocted as a progressive antidote to conformism [can be] instead charged with being an agent of that conformism on the aesthetic plane” (71). “[T]he postwar creative writing program was founded on the assumption that artists are forged in the imposition of ... institutional restraints upon unfettered creativity” (131). Of Alice Walker’s Jubilee he writes “[I]t performs the transformation of the peculiar institution of slavery into the enabling institution of creative writing” (165). And of the Iowa Workshop he writes,

    Squatting on the prairie, the Iowa Workshop remained connected to a larger world of normalized death and
   destruction, enlisting the literary imagination in the larger cause of the Free World. To this degree it was function-
   ing literally as an Ideological State Apparatus in Althusser’s sense. (175)

The latter third of The Program Era (1975-2008) addresses both the increase in lower middle class students in the universities and the awkward situation of a historically parochial United States within encroaching "transplanetary" cultures – diasporic, cosmopolitan, migratory, ethnic, racial, and other-national –  and the emergence of what McGurl calls “high cultural pluralism” as an ideology within which “categories that ... split the national culture into smaller units” have become “an easier sell for high cultural prestige leading to inclusion in the syllabus of post-war literature” (59). “[T]he literary cultural nationalisms of the sixties sought to liberate U.S. minority writers from the assimilative coercions of the American mainstream by symbolically affiliating them with decolonized peoples engaged in more literal acts of nation building. Of course, to describe these subnational-to-internationl links as ‘symbolic’ is to admit that in many if not most cases they have been ... fictional” (330-31). The is one of several observations in the book that could also apply to Canada – although perhaps not the cultural psychologizing that McGurl appends. In this period of class, ethnicity and racial self-consciousness, McGurl writes, “American literature is driven by a dialectic of shame and pride, self-hatred and self-esteem – a dialectic that is also, and not at all coincidentally, at the heart of American educational theory and practice” (284). It is a dialectic that in US fiction has led to minimalism, he argues, “an aesthetic of risk management, a way of being beautifully careful” (294), as well as to “maximalism” – a way of shielding oneself with words” (301).

    As an “embarassingly” programmatic product of the program, and unable, for all of its skills at understatement,
   to hide that fact from anyone very well, minimalism has the ironic advantage of revealing the systematicity of
   creativity in the Program Era in its starkest form. In doing so, it lays bare the recruitment of that creativity to the
   inhuman ends of the economic order we serve. (320)

Throughout McGurl wonders intermittently how uniquely “American” the creative writing program may be (and how insular his book) – toward the end exclaiming that the program is “as American as baseball, apple pie, and homicide” (364) and writing that its invention “in the United States is not narcissism alone” but an “embrace of both sides of the faintly paradoxical task of instituting individuality” (366) ( a task which could also strike an observer as rather “American”). As well as offering cultural explanations that he takes back to de Tocqueville, he points to material ones such as the decentralization of U.S. higher education (contrast the provincial regulation and funding of colleges and universities in Canada) and the tendency to fund students rather than institutions, which “ensures that most schools will have to compete for customers” (363).

In Canada there were single creative writing courses at some universities in the 1940s and 1950s. There were four in the English department calendar at UBC when I arrived in 1957, most likely because of the efforts of Earle Birney. Those moved from English to become part of a department – a US-style undergraduate program – within the Faculty of Fine Arts in 1964, effectively divorcing writing and literary studies; the program now offers an MFA. A similar Fine Arts department was established in the late 1970s at the University of Victoria. The less centralized interfaculty program which I designed at York University is still offered. Concordia University has been offering creative writing courses as part of its English degrees since the 1960s. The University of Calgary offers a somewhat more defined program within its Department of English, including MA and PhD. degrees with “concentration in Creative Writing” and a “creative thesis option.” The University of Guelph offers an MFA program in creative writing at its Guelph-Humber campus in Toronto. The University of British Columbia Okanagan offers an undergraduate creative writing degree within its Department of Creative and Critical Studies. Only the UBC (Vancouver) and UVic programs, and possibly that of Guelph, appear to have followed the US model.

FD

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    FRANK DAVEY: Poet, former Coach House Press editor, co-founder of TISH newsletter in 1961, co-founder of e-mag Swift Current in 1984, editor of poetics journal Open Letter, 'author' of Bardy Google in 2010 (Talonbooks), author of the tell-much biography of bpNichol, aka bpNichol in 2012 (ECW), and author of the recently published poetry collection Poems Suitable to Current Material Conditions (Mansfield). He has two other websites: a personal one at FrankDavey.net and one (co-managed with David Rosenberg) focused on poet bpNichol at  akabpNichol.net -- have a look!

    Postal Address: Books for review or other mail may be sent to FD at OPEN LETTER, 102 Oak Street, Strathroy, ON N7G 3K3, Canada

    -Bio/interview by 'Open Book'
    -Shorter bio/interview
    -Biography, online

    Categories

    All
    Adeena Karasick
    Agnes Threlkeld
    Aka Bpnichol
    Alan Edward McCartney
    Alan Reed
    Alice Munro
    Al Purdy
    Amodern
    Art Deco
    Artist's Homes
    Avant Garde
    Avant-garde
    Barack Obama
    Barbara Godard
    Barnicke Gallery
    Basil Bunting
    Battle
    Beauty
    Bill Bissett
    'Black Mountain'
    Bookthug
    BpNichol
    Buddhist Ecopoetics
    Canada At War
    Canadian Art
    Canadian Literature
    Canadian Pacific Railway
    Canadian War Lit
    CanLit Institution
    CanLit Teaching
    Ceramics
    Charles Bernstein
    Charles Olson
    Charles Olson
    Christian Bok
    Christine Miscione
    Christl Verduyn
    Climate Change
    Coach House Press
    Cold War
    Collaboration
    Conceptual Art In Britain
    Conceptual Poetry
    Concrete Poetry
    Creative Writing
    Daphne Marlatt
    Dennis Cooley
    Derek Beaulieu
    Devil's Artisan
    Donato Mancini
    Earle Birney
    Ecopoetry
    Emily Carr
    Epistolary Poems
    Eternal Network
    Eva Zeisel
    Ezra Pound
    Fetish Objects
    First World War
    Flarf
    Fluxus
    Frank Sanderson
    Franz Karl Stanzel
    Fred Wah
    Garry Thomas Morse
    General Idea
    George Bowering
    Gertrude Stein
    Greg Curnoe
    Gwendolyn MacEwen
    Gwynne Dyer
    Hart House
    Identity
    Indigenous Poetics
    Industrial Poetry
    Installation Art
    Irving Layton
    Jackson Mac Low
    Jacqueline Du Pasquier
    James Schuyler
    John Cage
    J.R. Colombo
    Judy Chicago
    Juliana Spahr
    Julian Assange
    Jussi Parikka
    Kathryn Mockler
    Kenneth Goldsmith
    Kevin Mcpherson Eckhoff
    Kit Dobson
    Language Poetry
    Laura Farina
    Laura Riding
    Lea Hindley-Smith
    Lemon Hound
    Leonard Cohen
    Lionel Kearns
    Lisa Anne Smith
    Lisa Robertson
    Literary Celebrity
    Literary Marketing
    Lola Tostevin
    Louis Dudek
    Louise Bourgeois
    Louis Zukofsky
    Love Letters
    Lyric Poetry
    Lytle Shaw
    Manifestos
    Mansfield Press
    Margaret Atwood
    Marjorie Perloff
    Max Laeuger
    Media Archaeology
    Michael Davidson
    Michael Morris
    Michael Ondaatje
    Mimesis
    Mina Loy
    Minimalism
    Misogyny In Poetry
    Modernism
    Nadezhda Tolokonnikova
    National Anthologies
    Nelson Ball
    Norman Yates
    Open Letter
    Pataphysics
    Paul Martin
    Peter Jaeger
    Peter-quartermain
    Philippe Petain
    Phyllis Webb
    Pierre Coupey
    Poetic Community
    Poetics
    Poetry Readings
    Procedural Art
    Public Poetics
    Pussy Riot
    Pussy Riot
    Rachel Blau Duplessis
    Rae Armantrout
    Robert Creeley
    Robert Duncan
    Robert Fitterman
    Robert Kroetsch
    Robert Lallemant
    Robert Lecker
    Ron Silliman
    Second World War
    Sharon Thesen
    Sherrill Grace
    Slavoj Žižek
    Smaro Kamboureli
    Stan Bevington
    Stan Dragland
    Stephen Voyce
    Steve Mccaffery
    Susan Bee
    Swiftcurrent
    Telidon
    Thea Bowering
    The Martyrology
    Theodor Adorno
    Tim Inkster
    TISH
    Tomson Highway
    Toronto Research Group
    Trg
    T.S. Eliot
    U-331
    U-Boat Surrenders
    Us Fiction
    Vimy Ridge
    Vincent Massey
    Visual Poetry
    Walter Benjamin
    Warren Tallman
    W.C. Williams
    Weardale
    Wikileaks

    Archives

    September 2020
    August 2017
    August 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly